One of the things that puzzles me are attempts to raise the retirement age, which I think is unnecessary and ignores human reality.
As people age, abilities unfortunately do tend to lessen and it's just not fair to tell someone 65 and older that they should compete against the younger workforce as if that's not true.
And I think the problem is the concept of "retirement" itself, which is not necessary for everyone at 65, and it can be deadly dangerous anyway, as if you go from being highly active to sitting in a rocking-chair doing nothing, you are likely to pass away sooner than later from the doing of nothing.
So rather than cruelly shift the age for "retirement" why not simply shift to an age related subsidy?
The current level of 65 is maintained, and people in advanced countries with social security simply start getting a check when that age is reached regardless of whether they have "retired" or not.
Those who choose to remain in the workforce will help their economies just by working and also would no longer pay into social security, which would be an additional benefit.
We can keep the current level of benefits without adjustment, for those, say, over 55, and evaluate the situation for those under, while noting that the 65 point of beginning of benefits is now locked in, without any reason to move it.
Monetary outlays may be less necessary in the future, with things like universal healthcare, and more efficient age related services, as, for instance, the United States throws away huge amounts of food on any given day.
Also in many areas, public transportation is not as good as in others, keeping more drivers in cars.
In a more efficient city, older citizens could enjoy a higher quality of life with less money if our society took it seriously and focused on reality versus political maneuverings that in the US usually are about cutting taxes for rich people, which is a subsidy as well!
It's just a more stupid one.
James Harris
Searching for meaningful answers beyond too typical commentary on important subjects.
Wednesday, April 25, 2012
Thursday, January 12, 2012
Health Insurance Responsibility
One of the most contentious issues in President Obama's healthcare plan is the requirement that people have health insurance, and while I supported him and Congress in getting the healthcare law passed, I've put forward what I think is a better idea where people can be responsible without being forced, while being kept accountable.
The healthcare idea I have is an important element of the Core Middle Party, an idea for a new political party that I put forward back in October. Critical to any party platform is a healthcare plan and a tax position. I'll talk here about the healthcare plan and how it removes the need for a healthcare mandate.
The key idea of my healthcare plan is allowing health insurance companies to remain businesses, and not charities, while leveraging their key strengths to help people stay healthy, and limit fraud and abuse, as keeping up with how some people try to cheat is what they do. It's their business.
Our federal government is just not as good at figuring out fraud and abuse as private companies, and is not as fast in implementing the best practices as learned from the market, meaning there are continual concerns about waste, fraud and abuse, so I recommend third party administration.
That is what the last company where I worked did, where despite being an insurance company themselves--though not in healthcare--they used United Healthcare to administer their healthcare plan for workers, but the company itself actually paid out claims. That is just a smart way to do things.
So how does that remove a health insurance mandate?
Under my plan people who are healthy and able to pay keep their health insurance like they do now. The one addition is that preventive care becomes automatically part of all plans. Otherwise, no changes.
They are under what I called Core Care.
Health insurance companies pick them because they are insurable. It is a business decision.
If someone is not normally insurable, they still have the same insurance company if they wish, and no health insurance company can refuse anyone. But the health insurance company might put them in the Expected Care tier, where they administer but the government pays.
That person would pay their insurance premiums to the U.S. Treasury.
So let's say someone chooses not to pay for health insurance despite being healthy and despite having the ability to pay. Then they get sick and apply for health insurance! No problem, the health insurance company signs them up and puts them in Expected Care, which also covers indigents who lack the ability to pay.
That is, the system covers everyone, and if someone cannot pay for regular health insurance, even if healthy, they'd go into Expected Care, as indigent.
If you chose not to get health insurance while healthy and got sick, you'd end up considered indigent by the system and the U.S. Treasury would pay for your care.
And the government might review your case and charge you later for your entire cost of care.
You had a chance to get insurance, so why didn't you? If you screwed up, you pay.
So if you screwed up by not getting health insurance when you could, it was your choice. But the consequences are up to legislators.
So what's the problem with other approaches?
Well let's say that a person under a system without mandated insurance decides to screw the system and not get health insurance until he is sick. Then the health insurance company is not then a business if it has to take him on--it becomes a charity.
Worse that person could be then rewarded for being irresponsible, and other people would pay for it.
Punishing them at that point could be more difficult for a private company as it's politically a hot issue. So it is an area for politicians.
In contrast, by allowing people to choose health insurance companies they can pick the ones who give the best service, without refusal being possible for those companies. While the health insurance companies have an incentive to keep people healthy, so that they pay premiums.
While for those who are beyond the realm of profit for private companies, our nation does the right thing and takes care of them, but doesn't administer so the private companies can help in catching fraud, waste and abuse.
I like this plan. To see my original presentation with all the 4 tiers including Core Care and Expected Care explained, you can look at a previous post on this blog.
How hard would it be to try it out?
Our government could means test by taking some people from Medicare and Medicaid and having them pick insurance companies who would third party administer, and we could see if it could work or not.
Those people would just get an insurance card like anyone for, say, United Healthcare, and I don't have any affiliation with them, as I lost my health insurance when I was laid off. For me, being covered by them is just a memory. Yes, I could have done the COBRA thing. No, have never done it as it's too damn expensive I think.
I've sent this plan to my congresswoman Nancy Pelosi, but more of you need to ask for it as well, as one person is not enough, and should not be enough. I like my ideas, as I should, they're mine. But can they really work? Not sure. But if other people think they might and ask for them, then our government might try.
Health insurance companies should not be considered enemies. Smart solutions can turn business strength into an asset for our entire country, bring down healthcare costs, and give people choice without a health insurance mandate.
But still allow accountability for those people who foolishly choose not to get health insurance anyway, when it becomes, universal.
James Harris
The healthcare idea I have is an important element of the Core Middle Party, an idea for a new political party that I put forward back in October. Critical to any party platform is a healthcare plan and a tax position. I'll talk here about the healthcare plan and how it removes the need for a healthcare mandate.
The key idea of my healthcare plan is allowing health insurance companies to remain businesses, and not charities, while leveraging their key strengths to help people stay healthy, and limit fraud and abuse, as keeping up with how some people try to cheat is what they do. It's their business.
Our federal government is just not as good at figuring out fraud and abuse as private companies, and is not as fast in implementing the best practices as learned from the market, meaning there are continual concerns about waste, fraud and abuse, so I recommend third party administration.
That is what the last company where I worked did, where despite being an insurance company themselves--though not in healthcare--they used United Healthcare to administer their healthcare plan for workers, but the company itself actually paid out claims. That is just a smart way to do things.
So how does that remove a health insurance mandate?
Under my plan people who are healthy and able to pay keep their health insurance like they do now. The one addition is that preventive care becomes automatically part of all plans. Otherwise, no changes.
They are under what I called Core Care.
Health insurance companies pick them because they are insurable. It is a business decision.
If someone is not normally insurable, they still have the same insurance company if they wish, and no health insurance company can refuse anyone. But the health insurance company might put them in the Expected Care tier, where they administer but the government pays.
That person would pay their insurance premiums to the U.S. Treasury.
So let's say someone chooses not to pay for health insurance despite being healthy and despite having the ability to pay. Then they get sick and apply for health insurance! No problem, the health insurance company signs them up and puts them in Expected Care, which also covers indigents who lack the ability to pay.
That is, the system covers everyone, and if someone cannot pay for regular health insurance, even if healthy, they'd go into Expected Care, as indigent.
If you chose not to get health insurance while healthy and got sick, you'd end up considered indigent by the system and the U.S. Treasury would pay for your care.
And the government might review your case and charge you later for your entire cost of care.
You had a chance to get insurance, so why didn't you? If you screwed up, you pay.
So if you screwed up by not getting health insurance when you could, it was your choice. But the consequences are up to legislators.
So what's the problem with other approaches?
Well let's say that a person under a system without mandated insurance decides to screw the system and not get health insurance until he is sick. Then the health insurance company is not then a business if it has to take him on--it becomes a charity.
Worse that person could be then rewarded for being irresponsible, and other people would pay for it.
Punishing them at that point could be more difficult for a private company as it's politically a hot issue. So it is an area for politicians.
In contrast, by allowing people to choose health insurance companies they can pick the ones who give the best service, without refusal being possible for those companies. While the health insurance companies have an incentive to keep people healthy, so that they pay premiums.
While for those who are beyond the realm of profit for private companies, our nation does the right thing and takes care of them, but doesn't administer so the private companies can help in catching fraud, waste and abuse.
I like this plan. To see my original presentation with all the 4 tiers including Core Care and Expected Care explained, you can look at a previous post on this blog.
How hard would it be to try it out?
Our government could means test by taking some people from Medicare and Medicaid and having them pick insurance companies who would third party administer, and we could see if it could work or not.
Those people would just get an insurance card like anyone for, say, United Healthcare, and I don't have any affiliation with them, as I lost my health insurance when I was laid off. For me, being covered by them is just a memory. Yes, I could have done the COBRA thing. No, have never done it as it's too damn expensive I think.
I've sent this plan to my congresswoman Nancy Pelosi, but more of you need to ask for it as well, as one person is not enough, and should not be enough. I like my ideas, as I should, they're mine. But can they really work? Not sure. But if other people think they might and ask for them, then our government might try.
Health insurance companies should not be considered enemies. Smart solutions can turn business strength into an asset for our entire country, bring down healthcare costs, and give people choice without a health insurance mandate.
But still allow accountability for those people who foolishly choose not to get health insurance anyway, when it becomes, universal.
James Harris
Thursday, October 27, 2011
The Core Middle Party
Increasing challenges as our nation moves into the 21st century have not been met by our current political parties, while technological change has given a unique in history opportunity for the voice of the people, including each individual to emerge.
For the first time in our history, each individual has the opportunity through connecting technology to put forward a position, a platform or even ideas for an entirely new political party, with the flexibility, vision, and objectivity to handle the needs of our new world. And we, the people, should not miss this opportunity to be heard.
So here in this post, I'll present the foundations for a new political party, envisioned to leap forward with the best of today, while holding on to the best of our past, as a nation, as a people who have always striven to keep getting better.
Wonderful thing about today is you can have your say, and what I say here is mine, and I hope many others take the opportunity to put forward even more of their own ideas, including new political parties, as we need change that works, and works for us.
Not just words, but real opportunity, real vision, and real progress so that we compete on the world stage at our best, literally being the best that we can be.
And who am I? Just one citizen, living in San Francisco, California, who is a registered Democrat, but I'd really like one day to put down my affiliation as: Core Middle Party
The Core Middle Party believes fundamentally that intelligent governance is what is needed, and that reality tells us: in an intelligently governed world people's lives tend to get better, not worse.
The role of government is to protect and enable its citizens.
All our rights under the Constitution of the United States and under the Declaration of Independence are re-affirmed.
The separation of church and state is a core value that goes to the heart of maintaining both our freedoms and our objectivity in seeing the world as it is, and not as some wish it to be.
And it guarantees the power of our plurality, with the recognition that as a nation we are better from the strengths in our differences than by trying to stand in a complex world on one particular religious point of view.
Freedom of speech, freedom of the press and the freedom to gather peacefully are critical to the health of the nation.
That there is a fundamental right to access to information, and also a fundamental right to privacy, as well as the right to, as best one can, choose one's own destiny, including as a matter of course, a woman's right to choose.
That in protecting its citizens government must maintain a strong defense, and face the world objectively, with the means to defend its citizens against all enemies foreign or domestic. And in so doing the the US military remains under civilian authority as it has always, from its founding.
Proper governance requires accountability.
Those who say one thing to gain office, in order to do something else, shall under this political party's platform face mechanisms for their recall or dismissal from office, sufficient to make this practice a thing of the past.
The need to care for those in need is fundamental to a modern, civilized healthy society, which requires education for all children, food for all children, and healthcare for all children.
The needs for a healthy populace require healthcare for all, paid for by the able.
In order for accountability, there must be transparency so that at all times the citizens know what their elected representatives are doing, so that if necessary corrective actions can be taken by a knowledgeable electorate.
As government requires funds, it is accepted that a progressive tax system is necessary for the proper funding of government, with no more complexity than necessary. And that cherished deductions are not part of political game playing, specifically, deductions for the care of children, the mortgage deduction, and charitable deductions are to remain.
These positions represent what is fundamental to the basic core of governance in an advanced, modern and just society. They do not represent all that is necessary, but are a guide to what can be, should be, as a template for working for an ever better nation.
The history of our nation is more brilliant for those who spoke up, and let themselves be heard, and today each person who is willing, has that potential to reach out to others and be heard.
The ideas here represent one approach, and more should speak, and more voices must be heard, as we, the people, should not miss this wonderful opportunity that technology has given us, which is to make our wishes, our hopes, our dreams for a better future be known.
For the betterment of us all.
James Harris
For the first time in our history, each individual has the opportunity through connecting technology to put forward a position, a platform or even ideas for an entirely new political party, with the flexibility, vision, and objectivity to handle the needs of our new world. And we, the people, should not miss this opportunity to be heard.
So here in this post, I'll present the foundations for a new political party, envisioned to leap forward with the best of today, while holding on to the best of our past, as a nation, as a people who have always striven to keep getting better.
Wonderful thing about today is you can have your say, and what I say here is mine, and I hope many others take the opportunity to put forward even more of their own ideas, including new political parties, as we need change that works, and works for us.
Not just words, but real opportunity, real vision, and real progress so that we compete on the world stage at our best, literally being the best that we can be.
And who am I? Just one citizen, living in San Francisco, California, who is a registered Democrat, but I'd really like one day to put down my affiliation as: Core Middle Party
The Core Middle Party believes fundamentally that intelligent governance is what is needed, and that reality tells us: in an intelligently governed world people's lives tend to get better, not worse.
The role of government is to protect and enable its citizens.
All our rights under the Constitution of the United States and under the Declaration of Independence are re-affirmed.
The separation of church and state is a core value that goes to the heart of maintaining both our freedoms and our objectivity in seeing the world as it is, and not as some wish it to be.
And it guarantees the power of our plurality, with the recognition that as a nation we are better from the strengths in our differences than by trying to stand in a complex world on one particular religious point of view.
Freedom of speech, freedom of the press and the freedom to gather peacefully are critical to the health of the nation.
That there is a fundamental right to access to information, and also a fundamental right to privacy, as well as the right to, as best one can, choose one's own destiny, including as a matter of course, a woman's right to choose.
That in protecting its citizens government must maintain a strong defense, and face the world objectively, with the means to defend its citizens against all enemies foreign or domestic. And in so doing the the US military remains under civilian authority as it has always, from its founding.
Proper governance requires accountability.
Those who say one thing to gain office, in order to do something else, shall under this political party's platform face mechanisms for their recall or dismissal from office, sufficient to make this practice a thing of the past.
The need to care for those in need is fundamental to a modern, civilized healthy society, which requires education for all children, food for all children, and healthcare for all children.
The needs for a healthy populace require healthcare for all, paid for by the able.
In order for accountability, there must be transparency so that at all times the citizens know what their elected representatives are doing, so that if necessary corrective actions can be taken by a knowledgeable electorate.
As government requires funds, it is accepted that a progressive tax system is necessary for the proper funding of government, with no more complexity than necessary. And that cherished deductions are not part of political game playing, specifically, deductions for the care of children, the mortgage deduction, and charitable deductions are to remain.
These positions represent what is fundamental to the basic core of governance in an advanced, modern and just society. They do not represent all that is necessary, but are a guide to what can be, should be, as a template for working for an ever better nation.
The history of our nation is more brilliant for those who spoke up, and let themselves be heard, and today each person who is willing, has that potential to reach out to others and be heard.
The ideas here represent one approach, and more should speak, and more voices must be heard, as we, the people, should not miss this wonderful opportunity that technology has given us, which is to make our wishes, our hopes, our dreams for a better future be known.
For the betterment of us all.
James Harris
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)